From Ministry to Membership: What Church Growth Taught Me About Gym Retention

When I tell gym owners that my background is in ministry, they usually pause. Then they smile politely, waiting for the connection. But the truth is, ministry and boutique fitness have more in common than you might think.

I spent over a decade helping churches grow—not by running ads or lowering barriers, but by creating systems that made people feel known. In ministry, growth isn’t about marketing; it’s about helping people belong. And that’s exactly what drives retention in your gym.

1. The First Visit Is Sacred

In church, we know that first impressions set the tone for everything. The first handshake, the welcome message, even the follow-up email—it all communicates: You matter here.

Gyms are no different. When a potential member walks through your door for a trial class, they’re not just testing your programming. They’re asking a deeper question: Do I fit here?

Your systems need to answer that question with a clear and resounding yes.

2. Consistency Builds Trust

One of the hardest parts of ministry is creating consistency—consistent communication, follow-up, and volunteer engagement. The same applies to member retention.

If your gym’s follow-up process depends on whether a coach remembers to send a text, you’re leaving growth up to chance. A simple, automated system ensures that every person feels pursued, not forgotten.

3. Belonging > Branding

Churches thrive when people move from attending to belonging. The same is true for gyms.

You can have the best programming in town, but if members don’t find community, they’ll eventually leave for a cheaper option. Retention doesn’t start with your workouts—it starts with relationships.

4. The Power of a Personal Touch

In ministry, handwritten notes, follow-up calls, and remembering someone’s story make all the difference.

In gyms, it’s checking in when a member misses class, celebrating milestones, or introducing new people to the community. These small touches create loyalty that marketing dollars can’t buy.

5. Systems That Serve People

I built Known & Co. on a simple belief: systems shouldn’t replace relationships—they should support them.

Just like in ministry, structure creates space for people to connect. Automations and CRMs aren’t about being impersonal; they free you up to do what you do best—build community.

⸻

Final Thought

Churches grow when people feel known. So do gyms.

That’s why my consulting model is built on the same principle: when your members feel seen, they stay.